Alice Catherine Millar was a young serving girl working at the Red Lion in 1638. According to local legend, she was brutally murdered by a jealous lover, stabbed to death in what is now Room 6. Her blood allegedly soaked into the wooden floorboards, leaving a stain that would reappear no matter how many times it was scrubbed clean.

Today, guests report seeing Alice's ghost dressed in a white gown, knocking on doors throughout the night. She's most commonly spotted in Rooms 5, 6, and 10, sometimes leaving behind mysterious blood-like stains that vanish by morning. The most chilling aspect of Alice's haunting is how she disappears - witnesses describe her walking straight through a wall where a doorway was bricked up over 200 years ago.

Many believe Alice is still searching for justice, or perhaps trying to warn other young women of the danger that befell her. Her presence is generally considered benevolent, though deeply melancholic.