The Bull at Wargrave is best known for the sorrowful spirit that haunts one of its upstairs bedrooms, now aptly named 'The Tear Room'. The primary reported phenomenon is the distinct sound of a woman crying, an auditory remnant of a tragedy that is said to have occurred in the 1820s. According to local lore, the landlord of the inn at that time discovered his wife had been unfaithful. In a fit of rage, he threw her out of the hotel and, most cruelly, forbade her from ever seeing their young child again. Overcome with grief and a broken heart, the woman is said to have died shortly after. Her weeping is believed to be a 'residual' haunting, replaying on the anniversary of her forced departure as she packed her belongings. In addition to this prominent story, there have been other, less frequent, reports of paranormal activity within the historic building. The apparition of a tall man wearing a black hat has allegedly been seen by guests and staff. This spectral figure is most often spotted in one of the lounge bars, sitting quietly near the large, open log fireplace. While the crying woman's story is tied to a specific room and a heart-wrenching narrative, the presence of the hatted man adds another layer to the inn's mysterious and haunted atmosphere, suggesting that more than one spirit may linger within its ancient walls.
The most pervasive and detailed paranormal account at The Bull at Wargrave revolves around the upstairs bedroom known as 'The Tear Room'. The story, originating in the 1820s, tells of a landlord's wife who was banished from the inn by her husband upon his discovery of her affair. The ultimate punishment was his refusal to let her see their baby. It is said that on the anniversary of the day she was forced to leave, the sounds of her inconsolable weeping can still be heard in the room as her spirit relives the agony of packing her belongings and leaving her child forever. This phenomenon is described not as an interactive haunting but as a residual one—an emotional imprint left on the very fabric of the location. Guests who have stayed in or near the room have reported being woken by the distinct sounds of sobbing, with no apparent physical source. There are no accounts of a full-bodied apparition connected to the crying woman; her presence is purely auditory, a perpetual echo of her profound sorrow.
A separate and distinct ghost story involves the sighting of a male entity in one of the public areas. Witnesses have described seeing a 'tall man wearing a black hat'. This figure is typically seen in the lounge bar, often seated near the grand inglenook fireplace, especially when a log fire is crackling during the winter months. Unlike the crying woman, this spirit is a visual apparition. Accounts suggest he is a quiet and non-threatening presence, simply observing the modern-day patrons of the inn he once may have frequented. Staff and guests have occasionally caught a glimpse of this dark figure out of the corner of their eye, only for him to vanish upon a second glance. The lack of interaction or sound associated with this apparition makes his origins and purpose a complete mystery, leaving observers to speculate on who he might have been and what keeps him tied to the old coaching inn.